blog post

By Lukas André. January 21, 2016

A Manifest for Net Neutrality

For more than two decades all traffic in the internet was substantially treated equally (referred to as “net neutrality”). With the raise of global content providers like Netflix that drive bandwidth consumption and threaten the offerings of residential internet service providers, a war on quality and costs for internet traffic has begun. Today the principle of net neutrality is under attack. It represents a fundamental shift in power in the internet economy, which threatens to undermine the competitive market structure that have served internet users so well and acted as a strong catalyst of innovation.

 

What is net neutrality?

Net neutrality is the principle that internet service providers and governments should treat all data on the internet the same, not discriminating or charging differentially by user, content, site, platform, application, type of attached equipment, or mode of communication (Wikipedia).

For the past two decades, the internet has operated as an unregulated free market. Backbone providers connect the content providers (websites) with residential internet service providers (ISPs). Settlement-free peering between the backbone providers ensures that every computer on the internet can reach every other computer. Competition among the providers helps to keep prices down and quality up and that there is no discrimination of websites or traffic.

 

The world of communication is changing

We consume more and more content from the internet. Many services that historically were consumed by end-users directly from a local telecom or cable operator (i.e. voice communication, text messaging, TV) are today accessed using new business models or for cheaper price from third-party companies via the internet (like Skype, Whatsapp or Netflix). Obviously, these third-party companies have an interest to get their content and services delivered at best quality to the end customers. But they are dependent on the backbone providers and ISPs. The increasing data traffic and demand for bandwidth drive investments into infrastructure of ISPs.

The ISPs or telecom and cable operators risk to get diminished to providers of data connectivity. At the same time, due to consolidation, the ISPs became powerful gatekeepers of the internet traffic. In search of new revenue models to finance investments into infrastructure, ISPs started to undermine net neutrality:

  1. Netflix ComcastOne example is to demand payment from content providers in order to provide quality peering and deliver their traffic at sufficient speed. ISPs attempt to ask for extra payment from content providers for a “fast lane”. A prominent example is the Comcast/Netflix dispute from 2013/14. Accessing Netflix content for Comcast customers was becoming slower and slower. And only when Netflix finally agreed to a payment to Comcast, the speed of Netflix service for Comcast clients dramatically increased. Charging for traffic on both sides of the line is called “double paid traffic”. The problem of fast vs. slow traffic lane and double paid traffic is an issue for many successful content provider today but often not visible to the public.
  2. A more visible violation of net neutrality is called “zero rating”. Mobile operators enter into partnership with selected content providers and exclude their traffic from the charge/quota of the customers’ subscription. Salt for example has a commercial partnership with Zattoo and does not charge the traffic for watching their streamed video content. It gives Zattoo a commercial advantage over its competition.

 

Giving up net neutrality will slowdown innovation

These developments represent a fundamental shift in power in the internet economy. Of course, investments into infrastructure by ISPs need to be covered by relevant revenues. But this is why we pay a subscription fee. As customers we should accept that access to internet has a certain cost. ISPs should not start a war on subscription prices. If we allow to undermine net neutrality for cheaper subscription prices, we change a competitive market structure that has served internet users so well for the past two decades:

  1. Freedom of choice of users to access websites and services globally
  2. Equal opportunities for all players in the internet economy

It was this freedom of the internet that acted as catalyst for the development of new, innovative business models and brought game changers for our daily life: Skype for voice communication, Whatsapp for text messaging, Netflix for TV and DVDs, Spotify for CDs, Dropbox for data storage, just to name a few. It is the ease of distribution and equal opportunities for all player in the internet economy that makes it possible for a start-up to conquer a whole industry. In an economy where ISPs as gate keepers can discriminate offerings against other, it will become easier for established players to protect their current market position. Larger customer bases and stronger cash flow will allow them to negotiate better deals with ISPs. Thus, it will get more difficult for innovators to challenge the status quo. We will see a slowdown of innovation.
John Oliver on his show Last Week Tonight (HBO) brought it to the point. It’s fun and worthwhile to watch:

 

Regulation is required
Various countries have taken on the problem with different solutions. In Europe in Fall 2015 the European Parliament voted for net neutrality but with a significant exception for “special services”. “Special services” should be allowed to be treated differently on the network. Unfortunately a clear definition of “special services” is missing. While some politicians see “special services” to be a small amount of specific services to serve public good (like telemedicine or emergency services), Deutsche Telecom and Vodafone see the new law as an open door to classify online services like Spotify as a special service against a revenue share.

In the US, FCC (Federal Communications Commission) went much further and voted early 2015 in favor of a strong net neutrality rule to keep the internet open and free. In fact, FCC reclassified broadband as a common carrier under Communications Act. The FCC sided with many consumers, small businesses, entrepreneurs, and prospective startup companies. During the meeting FCC Chairman Wheeler said: “This is the FCC using all the tools in our toolbox to protect innovators and consumers to ban paid prioritization [...]. Consumers will get what they pay for, unfettered access to any lawful content on the Internet.” President Obama supported the stricter regulation, too. Watch his statement here:

 

And where is Switzerland? A partial revision of the Telecommunications Act is currently in consultation (until end of March 2016). Based on the current draft, special treatment of specific services and content will be explicitly allowed. The ISPs will only have to inform transparently if they treat traffic of specific services or content differently. This is too weak. Our internet start-ups risks to fall behind in a global competition. Only if we follow a similar path as the FCC in the US and protect net neutrality in Switzerland unconditionally can we protect the innovativeness of our start-up industry.

 

Affentranger Associates supports start-ups as a principal investor and advisor. Telecom, media and technology is one of our focus areas. In December we have successfully supported the private capital placement of Exoscale, an innovative cloud service provider in Switzerland (www.exoscale.ch). Exoscale’s ambition is to become the leading cloud hosting platform for SaaS companies. Exoscale is committed to provide unfettered access to its platform for all internet users.

comment

email
marya@myumail.website

Nicely put, Thanks a lot!
discount drugs online pharmacy

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Looking for a boyfriend!!!
Register and write me my nickname Xenia21
link to my free webcam
http://b.link/mysexcam/

email
wwweeestta@mail.ru

Cumpara Raѕpbеrry Pi 3 Mannequin B 1 Gb RAM de la eMAG!

Also visit myy webb site :: buckliston8837.wikidot.com

email
brycefurman@gmail.com

Information clearly utilized..
buy prescription drugs canada

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Thanks a lot. Good information.
online pharmacy no prescription

email
bakos595izm@post.com
email
delarosas@mypop3.website

Nicely put. Cheers!
http://talahicc.com/ - pharmacy price comparison

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

Thanks a lot. Plenty of forum posts!

prescription drugs canada

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Tips effectively considered!.
mail order pharmacy

email
bakos595izm@post.com
email
norene@hostingninja.website

Thank you, A good amount of write ups.

best canadian pharmacies

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

suck well hung
comodo memory firewall sucks
free streaming animan porn
chick hardbodies sexy
step teaches masturbation

sex warriors cartoon

sex young video
a Good Rub Call
sexual mind control story
vicki masson nude
black female queer sexality

email
k.r.ulov.v.v1.98.1.1.1@gmail.com

Киев. Самое выгодное для больных суставов. Gelenk-Nahrung https://prom.ua/Gelenk-narung.html Pro Vista AG Германия. В Украине. Геленг Нарунг при артритах и артрозах, от боли в суставах, в позвоночнике, при остеохондрозе, травмах, переломах в послеоперационный период, Хрящи, ревматизм, Коллаген, Питание для суставов. Банка 600 грамм, на 3 месяца. Срок годности 2 года. Viber+Whatsapp +38097-189-86-55, +380689231360

email
fev.gen708@gmail.com

Perfectly voiced certainly. !
24 hour pharmacy

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Whoa a lot of excellent information!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/ - canadian prescriptions

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

You definitely made your point.
canadian pharmacy without prescription

email
bakos595izm@post.com

Great postings. Thank you!
canadian pharma companies

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Thanks! I like this.
discount drugs online pharmacy

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Thanks! Awesome stuff.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/ - canadian pharma companies

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

Cheers, Quite a lot of stuff.

pharmacy without dr prescriptions

email
bakos595izm@post.com

Useful knowledge. Appreciate it!
best canadian mail order pharmacies

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Qcharge inc. is launching Qfino Quick charge, wireless and solar powerbank
Click here to get a chance to win free and by sharing link you can earn pints,
http://bit.ly/qfino_powerbank

email
londonpromo1119@gmail.com

Cheers. Wonderful information.
http://www.nicktambone.com/ - northwestpharmacy

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

Thank you! Loads of stuff.

canadian drugs

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

You suggested this exceptionally well!
legitimate online pharmacies

email
bakos595izm@post.com

Superb info. Regards!
highest rated canadian pharmacies

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Amazing plenty of helpful information.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/ - canada drug pharmacy

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

Thanks. An abundance of postings!

canadian pharmacy 365

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Incredible plenty of amazing advice!
prescription price comparison

email
bakos595izm@post.com

Beneficial forum posts. Kudos.
online pharmacy

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Thank you, Wonderful stuff!
online pharmacy without prescription

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com
email
odette@mail2k.website

You actually explained it well!
medical information online

email
bakos595izm@post.com

Truly quite a lot of amazing information!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/ - canada online pharmacy

email
honour389ogl@keromail.com

Thanks a lot. Ample postings!

the canadian pharmacy

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

I really want to fuck!
You can see how I fuck myself in the ass on the camera!
Register and write me my nickname Xenia21
Here is a link to my camera >>>
http://b.link/mysexcam/

email
wwweeestta@mail.ru

This is nicely put! !
canadian pharmacy online canada

email
lucasPaymn@gmail.com

Nicely put, Kudos.
prescription drugs prices

email
bakos595izm@post.com

leave a reply

(Your email will not be publicly displayed.)

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
back to the aasa blog